A Guide to Investing in CLO Equity Funds: Essential Insights

The collateralized loan obligation (CLO) market has grown significantly over the past 35 years, evolving into a $1.1 trillion pillar of corporate financing, with US BSL CLOs accounting for about 68% of demand for US corporate loans.

CLO equity captures the difference between loan interest earned and debt owed to CLO debtholders, offering a unique investment opportunity with potential double-digit returns. This asset CLO investments class combines the benefits of private equity with bond-like cash flows.

Main Points

• CLO equity represents a high-risk, high-reward tranche within the $1.1 trillion CLO market.
• Investors can benefit from double-digit returns with quarterly distributed cash flows.
• Grasping how CLO equity works is key to assessing its role in a diversified portfolio.
• CLO equity behaves differently from traditional fixed income or equity investments.
• Investors must weigh both the upsides and dangers prior to deployment.

CLO Equity Fundamentals

Understanding CLO equity starts with knowing how Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) are structured. A CLO functions like a corporate entity, raising capital to acquire a diversified pool of leveraged loans. Typically, it invests in between 150 and 350 leveraged loans that act as security for the CLO.

What Are Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs)?

Collateralized Loan Obligations (CLOs) are structured credit instruments that pool together a diverse collection of leveraged loans, creating a securitized investment vehicle with multiple tranches of varying risk and return profiles. Such a layered structure provides a menu of risk/return slices for various investor appetites.

Equity Tranches Explained

Sitting at the base of the capital stack, the equity slice is vital to a CLO’s design. Being most junior, it takes initial losses yet enjoys first claim on surplus cash after debt obligations are met. Thus, equity investors bear the lion’s share of credit risk but can reap outsized rewards.

Return Drivers of CLO Equity

Returns on the equity tranche stem from the net interest spread after servicing debt tranches. This creates a leveraged exposure to corporate credit, making CLO equity an attractive option for investors seeking higher yields. Understanding the floating-rate nature of both the underlying loans and the CLO debt is crucial to appreciating how CLO equity performs across different interest rate environments.

The Structure of CLO Equity Funds

Understanding the structure of CLO equity funds is crucial for investors looking to diversify their portfolios. Such funds pool capital to buy exposure to the equity slices of multiple CLOs.

CLO Funding Stack and Waterfall Payments

The CLO structure features a hierarchical “waterfall” payment system. This system determines how cash flows are distributed among the various tranches. Only once fees and senior debt are paid does the leftover spread flow to equity holders. Each quarter, the waterfall ensures seniors are paid first, then equity gets the residual.

• The CLO funding stack places equity at the bottom of the capital structure, creating a 10:1 leverage ratio that amplifies both potential returns and risks for equity investors.
• This structure creates inherent risk mitigation for debt tranches through overcollateralization and interest coverage tests.

Risk Characteristics of Equity Tranches

As the most junior, equityholders absorb loan defaults before any debt tranche is affected. Yet in strong credit markets, equityholders enjoy the lion’s share of excess returns. CLO equity funds typically hold positions in multiple CLO equity tranches, providing diversification across different CLO managers, vintages, and underlying loan portfolios to mitigate concentration risk.

Equity investors must grasp these built-in guards and tilt factors, since they shape when and how much cash flows to them.

Why Invest in CLO Equity Funds?

CLO equity investments have gained popularity due to their potential for generating substantial returns through quarterly distributions. This investment vehicle offers a unique combination of attractive returns, front-loaded cash flows, and diversification benefits, making it an appealing option for investors seeking to enhance their portfolios.

Attractive Return Potential

CLO equity funds offer investors the potential for double-digit annual returns, delivered through quarterly distributions. This creates an attractive time-weighted return profile compared to other alternative investments. The CLO equity asset class has historically provided strong returns, making it an attractive option for investors seeking yield.

Early Cash-Out Advantage

The front-loaded cash flow pattern of CLO equity investments contrasts sharply with the typical J-curve effect seen in private equity. This provides investors with earlier access to returns and reduces the weighted average life of the investment, making it a more attractive option for those seeking liquidity.

Diversification Advantages

Investing in CLO equity also offers portfolio diversification benefits. Its historic correlations often remain below 50% versus fixed income peers like high-yield. This makes CLO equity an excellent addition to a diversified investment portfolio.

Key Risks Associated with CLO Equity Investments

Understanding the risks associated with CLO equity is crucial for investors looking to diversify their portfolios. They carry distinctive hazards that must be weighed alongside their upside potential.

Credit Risk and Default Concerns

CLO equity holders face pronounced credit risk. Defaults in the underlying loan portfolio directly impact equity returns before affecting any other tranche in the CLO structure. As the first-loss position, effective credit oversight is nonnegotiable.

• Defaults directly impact equity returns.
• Losses funnel first to the equity layer.
• Credit risk management is essential for mitigating potential negative outcomes.

Market Volatility Impact

Price swings can sharply move CLO equity valuations. The financing terms can avert fire sales, but M2M swings still pose valuation risk.

Liquidity Considerations

CLO equity liquidity merits careful review. Stress periods may choke secondary trading, hampering exits. Understanding these liquidity risks is vital for investors.

• The secondary market can become constrained during market stress.
• Exits may be delayed or costly when liquidity dries up.
• Proper risk management includes considering liquidity risks.

In conclusion, while CLO equity investments offer attractive returns, they are accompanied by significant risks, including credit risk, market volatility, and liquidity concerns. Investors must carefully evaluate these risks and consider strategies for mitigation.

The Power of Active Management

Active portfolio steering is crucial to unlocking CLO equity value. By continually monitoring and adjusting the portfolio, skilled managers can significantly enhance returns for equity investors.

Reinvestment Phase Benefits

In the 4–5 year reinvestment window, managers can trade up holdings to capture fresh value. Such proactive recalibrations are vital to amplify CLO equity upside.

Par Building Strategies

Buying loans below par can translate a small discount into outsized equity gains via leverage. A discount of 2% can translate to a 20% benefit for equity investors, highlighting the importance of strategic trading decisions during the reinvestment period.

Debt Optimization Techniques

Managers can also refinance or reset debt to tweak the capital structure in favor of equity. Lowering borrowing costs or prolonging the reinvestment window lets equityholders capture more value when markets permit.

Active management represents a critical value driver for CLO equity investments. Skilled managers can enhance returns through strategic trading decisions, par building strategies, and refinancing options, ultimately creating significant value for equity investors.

CLO Equity vs. Other Alternative Investments

The distinct profile of CLO equity sets it apart from traditional alternative investments. Investors weighing alts should map how CLO equity stacks up on return, duration, and liquidity.

Comparison with Private Equity

Unlike private equity’s long hold and J-curve, CLO equity delivers early, regular cash. CLO equity starts paying out within roughly half a year, shunning the typical PE J-curve. This results in a shorter investment duration, typically ranging from 3-5 years, compared to the 7-10 years associated with private equity. Additionally, CLO equity offers more predictable cash flows and greater liquidity, although it may yield lower total returns in strong market environments.

During reinvestment phases, annualized equity cash-on-cash returns have often hit the mid- to high-teens. That, along with a briefer time horizon, positions it well for investors wanting speedier payback.

CLO Equity vs. Fixed Income

Relative to traditional fixed income and credit investments, CLO equity provides significantly higher return potential, albeit with higher risk and less liquidity. The floating-rate nature of CLO assets and liabilities creates a different interest rate sensitivity profile, potentially making CLO equity more resilient during rising rate environments. Such nuances should guide how much capital to allocate to CLO equity in a balanced alt portfolio.

CLO Equity Performance Across Market Cycles

Investors often overlook the ongoing potential of CLO equity, assuming its heyday is over. Yet, it has shown strong resilience and counterintuitive returns in various cycles.

Downturn Performance

Equity prices may wobble in recessions. But the financing terms avert fire-sales, giving managers a chance to buy loans on the cheap and boost longer-run yields. Notably, some of the strongest-performing CLO equity vintages were issued just before periods of market stress, such as in 2007, enabling them to acquire loans at significant discounts during their reinvestment periods.

Rising vs. Falling Rate Environments

In rising rate environments, CLO equity benefits from the floating-rate nature of both its assets and liabilities. Its net sensitivity hinges on how much more assets reset than debt. Understanding these dynamics helps investors develop effective vintage diversification strategies when allocating to CLO equity.

Its adaptability across regimes cements its role as a compelling diversifier. Its performance is influenced by a combination of factors, including the manager’s skill in navigating market cycles and the inherent characteristics of CLO structures.

Accessing CLO Equity Fund Investing Opportunities

Investors seeking to tap into CLO equity funds have multiple avenues to consider, each with its unique advantages and considerations.

Direct Deal-by-Deal Investments

Direct deal-by-deal investments in CLO equity offer sophisticated investors maximum control and customization. You can select managers and deal structures tailored to your goals. However, it requires significant expertise and resources to analyze and manage a portfolio of CLO equity positions effectively.

Captive Equity Funds

Captive funds pool capital to buy broad CLO equity baskets. A seasoned manager then navigates vintages and credit selection on behalf of the fund. It lowers the entry barrier and dampens single-vintage swings via built-in diversification.

Credit Fund Alternatives

Multi-asset or opportunistic credit funds offer a simplified way to gain exposure to CLO equity as part of a broader credit investment portfolio. Although you lose some pure-play benefits, you gain multi-credit diversification under a single strategy. Review objectives and cost structures closely before committing.

Which route you pick hinges on your capital, expertise, and desired customization. Larger institutional investors often prefer direct investments, while smaller investors may benefit from fund structures that offer diversification and professional management.

Manager Selection: Critical Factors for Success

Effective CLO equity investing hinges on selecting a skilled manager. A manager’s portfolio design, research depth, and trade execution shape final equity yields.

Proven Performance

Past performance and tenure speak volumes about a manager’s market navigation skills. Consistency across vintage cycles is a key due-diligence metric.

Investment Philosophy and Risk Management Approach

The investment philosophy and risk management approach of a CLO manager can significantly vary. Some chase high current payouts; others emphasize downside protection and long-term gains. Assess their credit research depth and workout strategies for stressed loans.

When selecting a manager, it’s essential to consider their risk management strategy and how it aligns with your investment goals. Strategic alignment often translates into superior risk-adjusted results.

Final Thoughts on CLO Equity

CLO equity offers a distinct combination of return potential and diversification benefits, making it a valuable consideration for sophisticated investors. With its attractive, double-digit return potential and front-loaded cash flows, CLO equity can enhance risk-adjusted returns in a diversified investment portfolio.

For investors with the appropriate risk tolerance and investment horizon, CLO equity can serve as a valuable portfolio diversifier due to its low correlation with traditional asset classes. Review your risk profile, liquidity needs, and current allocations to decide if CLO equity fits.